On the politics of fear
The role of politicians in stoking Islamophobia during the COVID-19 pandemic in India
Muslims, India’s largest minority group, have often found themselves excluded from the country’s mainstream political power circles. The historically constructed clash between Muslims and Hindus has been used by the members of the far right – such as the Rāṣtriya Svayaṃsevak Saṇgh (RSS) or the Viśva Hindū Pariṣada (VHP) – to present the Muslim community as outsiders and ill-intentioned others with a view to subjugating the Hindu majority. There has been a notable rise in majoritarianism since the Bhāratiya Janata Party (BJP) rose to power in 2014. Prior to the outbreak of COVID-19, many BJP and RSS members made overtly racist remarks and incited violence against the Muslim community. The COVID-19 pandemic appears to have exacerbated this religious polarisation that has been gradually intensifying since Narendra Modi (BJP) won a landslide re-election victory in May 2019. Fears surrounding the pandemic have rapidly fuelled societal divisions, as well as hyper-nationalism and religious extremism targeted at Indian Muslims. A tarnished social fabric would have obvious long-term ramifications, specifically relating to stigmatisation, stereotyping and violent attacks. In this paper, the author will attempt to examine the role of BJP politicians in stoking Islamophobia. The author will address the question of whether the COVID-19 pandemic has been politicised against the Muslim minority. Are politicians primarily responsible for stoking intercommunal fear and hatred? What roles have state actors played in fomenting sectarian discord during COVID-19? This article tackles these and other salient questions pertaining to the politicisation of the coronavirus outbreak and mounting hate speech authorised by the ruling party in India. The article concludes by suggesting that Hindutva-driven Islamophobia, supported by the BJP government, may have permeated the Hindu mainstream but cautions that this claim still needs empirical validation. This article informs readers of the specific process of Islamophobic violence during the COVID-19 pandemic which remains a largely understudied phenomenon in India. My interpretation is partially based on spending two months doing fieldwork, mainly in New Delhi, in February and March 2020 during the coronavirus outbreak.
Bharatiya Janata Party; BJP; coronavirus; corona jihad; COVID-19; Hindutva; Islamophobia; Narendra Modi; disinformation; fake news
“Can’t end terror until we uproot Islam,” said minister Anantkumar Hegde. Old video surfaces, “New Delhi Television” [online], 8 XII 2017 [access: 29 II 2021]: <https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/union-minister-anantkumar-hegde-cant-wipe-out-terrorism-till-we-uproot-islam-1785351>.
“Insight”, 4 II 1991.
“Tattle” [online, access: 27 I 2021]: <https://tattle.co.in/>.
ABP News invents “research” to praise Modi. BJP’s Amit Malviya amplifies the fake news, “News Laundry” [online], 10 IV 2020 [access: 29 II 2021]: <https://www.newslaundry.com/2020/04/10/abp-news-invents-research-to-praise-modi-bjps-amit-malviya-amplifies-the-fake-news>.
Aditya Bharadwaj K.V., Volunteers distributing relief material attacked, “The Hindu” [online], 6 IV 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/karnataka/volunteers-distributing-relief-material-attacked/article31274032.ece>.
Afeef M., Does law allow calls to boycott Muslims during the COVID-19 lockdown?, “The Wire” [online], 28 V 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://thewire.in/communalism/covid-19-lockdown-muslims-boycott-law>.
Akbar S., Kukreti D., Sagarika S., Pal J., Temporal patterns in COVID-19 related digital misinformation in India, “Joyojeet Pal” [online], 16 IV 2020 [access: 27 I 2021]: <http://joyojeet.people.si.umich.edu/temporal-patterns-in-covid-19-misinformation-in-india/>.
Anderson J., Rainie L., The future of truth and misinformation online, “Pew Research Center” [online], 19 X 2017 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2017/10/19/the-future-of-truth-and-misinformation-online/>.
Arya S., Muslims face social boycott in Buldhana, business too hit, “The Times of India” [online], 20 IV 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/muslims-face-social-boycott-in-buldhana-business-too-hit/articleshow/75102273.cms>.
Ashraf A., How Modi’s BJP lagged on COVID-19 response in Central India, “TRT World” [online], 21 IV 2020 [access: 15 VI 2020]: <https://www.trtworld.com/magazine/how-modi-s-bjp-lagged-on-covid-19-response-in-central-india-35617>.
Bagchi S., The religion of business, “Mint” [online], 13 IV 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://www.livemint.com/mint-lounge/features/the-religion-of-business-11586495537981.html>.
Banaji S., Bhat R., Disinformation against Indian Muslims during the COVID-19 pandemic, “Students against Hindutva Ideology” [online], 15 IX 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.studentsagainsthindutvaideology.org/post/disinformation-against-indian-muslims-during-the-covid-19-pandemic>.
Bansal S., Poonam S., Misinformation is endangering India’s election, “The Atlantic” [online], 1 IV 2019 [access: 27 III 2021]: <https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2019/04/india-misinformation-election-fake-news/586123/>.
Bayer J., Bitiukova N., Bárd P., Szakács J., Alemanno A., Uszkiewicz E., Disinformation and propaganda – impact on the functioning of the rule of law in the EU and its Member States, Policy Department for Citizens’ Rights and Constitutional Affairs, European Union February 2019: <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2019/608864/IPOL_STU(2019)608864_EN.pdf> [access: 27 XII 2020].
Brennen J.S., Simon F., Howard P.N., Nielsen R.K., Types, sources, and claims of COVID-19 misinformation, “Reuters Institute” [online], 7 IV 2020 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/types-sources-and-claims-covid-19-misinformation>.
Chatterji A.P., Hansen T.B., Jaffrelot C., Majoritarian state. How Hindu nationalism is changing India, Oxford University Press, 2019.
Chaudhuri P., Amit Malviya’s fake news fountain: 16 pieces of misinformation spread by the BJP IT cell chief, “Scroll” [online], 10 II 2020 [access: 10 III 2021]: <https://scroll.in/article/952731/amit-malviyas-fake-news-fountain-16-pieces-of-misinformation-spread-by-the-bjp-it-cell-chief>.
Chowdhury A., Fake news in the time of coronavirus. A Boom study, “Boom” [online], 8 V 2020 [access: 27 II 2021]: <https://www.boomlive.in/fact-file/fake-news-in-the-time-of-coronavirus-a-boom-study-8008/page-2>.
Countries with the most Facebook users 2021, “Statista” [online], 9 II 2021 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.statista.com/statistics/268136/top-15-countries-based-on-number-of-facebook-users>.
Countries with the most Twitter users 2021, “Statista” [online, access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.statista.com/statistics/242606/number-of-active-twitter-users-in-selected-countries/>.
COVID-19: was Tablighi Jamaat event the only mass gathering leading up to the lockdown?, “Sabrang” [online], 18 IV 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://sabrangindia.in/article/covid-19-was-tablighi-jamaat-event-only-mass-gathering-leading-lockdown>.
Defying lockdown, devotees in Bengal assemble at temples on Ram Navami, “The Hindu” [online], 2 IV 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/kolkata/defying-lockdown-devotees-in-bengal-assemble-at-temples-on-ram-navami/article31237211.ece>.
Ellis-Petersen H., Rahman S.A., Coronavirus conspiracy theories targeting Muslims spread in India, “The Guardian” [online], 13 IV 2020 [access: 29 V 2020]: <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/13/coronavirus-conspiracy-theories-targeting-muslims-spread-in-india>.
Fact Check, “Boom” [online, access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.boomlive.in/fact-check>.
Fake Alert: Long list of Islamophobic fake news which is going viral during coronavirus pandemic, “Media Scanner” [online], 16 V 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://mediascanner.in/fake-alert-long-list-of-islamophobic-fake-news-which-is-going-viral-during-coronavirus-pandemic/>.
FIR against UP hospital which wouldn’t allow Muslim patients without COVID-19 test, “The Wire” [online], 20 IV 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://thewire.in/communalism/fir-meerut-hospital-muslim-patients-covid-19>.
From spreading fake news on JNU to garnering support for CAA through dubious claims, netizens are calling out BJP’s IT cell, “Firstpost” [online], 8 I 2020 [access: 27 III 2021]: <https://www.firstpost.com/india/from-fake-news-on-jnu-attack-to-luring-people-to-back-caa-through-false-promises-bjps-gargantuan-it-cell-is-being-called-out-by-netizens-7876491.html>.
Government bans 59 mobile apps which are prejudicial to sovereignty and integrity of India, defence of India, security of state and public order, “Government of India Press Information Bureau” [online], 29 VI 2020 [access: 30 VI 2020]: <https://pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=1635206#>.
Hasan M., The coronavirus is empowering Islamophobes – but exposing the idiocy of Islamophobia, “The Intercept” [online], 14 IV 2020 [access: 15 VI 2020]: <https://theintercept.com/2020/04/14/coronavirus-muslims-islamophobia/>.
How fake news is fuelling India’s nationalism, “South China Morning Post” [online], 14 VII 2017 [access: 30 I 2021]: <https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/south-asia/article/2102639/how-fake-news-fuelling-indias-nationalism>.
India and misinformation, Storyful, August 2018: <https://storyful.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Storyful-White-Paper-India-August-2018.pdf> [access: 29 I 2021].
India: aftermath of hateful Islamophobic campaign and fake news amidst corona virus pandemic, “Media Scanner” [online], 14 IV 2020 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://mediascanner.in/india-aftermath-of-hateful-islamophobic-campaign-and-fake-news-amidst-corona-virus-pandemic>.
India’s Modi cleared of complicity in deadly communal riots, “Vanguard” [online], 11 XII 2019 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://www.vanguardngr.com/2019/12/indias-modi-cleared-of-complicity-in-deadly-communal-riots/>.
Iqbal M., WhatsApp revenue and usage statistics (2021), “Business of Apps” [online], 17 XII 2021 [access: 17 XII 2021]: <https://www.businessofapps.com/data/whatsapp-statistics>.
Islamophobia Research & Documentation Project, Center for Race & Gender, University of California, Berkeley 2019: <https://www.crg.berkeley.edu/research/islamophobia-research-documentation-project/> [access: 27 IV 2021].
Islamophobia. A challenge for us all, The Runnymede Trust, 1997: <https://www.runnymedetrust.org/companies/17/74/Islamophobia-A-Challenge-for-Us-All.html> [access: 27 XI 2020].
Islamophobia. Still a challenge for us all. A 20th-anniversary report, ed. F. Elahi, O. Khan, Runnymede, 2017: <https://www.runnymedetrust.org/uploads/Islamophobia%20Report%202018%20FINAL.pdf> [access: 27 XI 2020].
Jain A., BJP ignores PM Modi’s social distancing advice at Shivraj Singh Chouhan’s oath taking, “Huffington Post” [online], 24 III 2020 [access: 15 VI 2020]: <https://www.huffingtonpost.in/entry/bjp-madhya-pradesh-social-distancing-shivraj-singh-chouhan_in_5e79a7bbc5b62f90bc508234>.
Kasparov G., The point of modern propaganda isn’t only to misinform or push an agenda. It is to exhaust your critical thinking, to annihilate truth, “Twitter. Garry Kasparov” [online], 13 XII 2016 [access: 27 XI 2020]: <https://twitter.com/kasparov63/status/808750564284702720?lang=he>.
Kesar S., Abraham R., Lahoti R., Nath P., Basole A., Pandemic, informality, and vulnerability. Impact of COVID-19 on livelihoods in India, Centre for Sustainable Employment, June 2020 (CSE Working Paper, 27): <https://cse.azimpremjiuniversity.edu.in/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Kesar_et_al_Pandemic_Informality_Vulnerability_June_2020.pdf> [access: 20 III 2021].
Krishnan M., How fake news is widening social rifts in India, “Deutsche Welle” [online], 9 X 2017 [access: 15 IV 2021]: <https://www.dw.com/en/how-fake-news-is-widening-social-rifts-in-india/a-40875997>.
Lewis B., Why influence matters in the spread of misinformation, “Data & Society” [online], 20 XI 2018 [access: 29 I 2021]: <https://points.datasociety.net/why-influence-matters-in-the-spread-of-misinformation-fc99ee69040e>.
Lewis R., Marwick A., Media manipulation and disinformation online, Data & Society, 15 V 2017: <https://datasociety.net/library/media-manipulation-and-disinfo-online/> [access: 29 II 2021].
Maizland L., India’s Muslims: an increasingly marginalized population, “Council on Foreign Relations” [online], 20 VIII 2020 [access: 27 XI 2020]: <https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/india-muslims-marginalized-population-bjp-modi>.
Malviya A., Delhi’s dark underbelly is exploding! [...], “Twitter. Amit Malviya” [online], 31 III 2020 [access: 29 II 2021]: <https://twitter.com/amitmalviya/status/1245083081305776128?s=20>.
Massive crackdown on fake news! Facebook removes 687 pages linked to Congress IT cell, “Financial Express” [online], 1 IV 2019 [access: 28 III 2021]: <https://www.financialexpress.com/elections/massive-crackdown-on-fake-news-facebook-removes-687-pages-linked-to-congress-it-cell/1534375/>.
Mounika A.S., Video: Karnataka panchayat bans and ostracises Muslims over COVID-19 stigma, “The News Minute” [online], 9 IV 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/video-karnataka-panchayat-bans-and-ostracises-muslims-over-covid-19-stigma-122222>.
Murthy L., The contagion of hate In India, Association for Progressive Communications, November 2020: <https://www.apc.org/sites/default/files/APC_Hate_Speech_V10_0.pdf> [access: 15 VI 2020].
News Laundry, TV Newsance Episode 77: Delhi election and Amit Malviya’s fakery, “You Tube” [online], 9 II 2020 [access: 29 II 2021]: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WJdCcXQtW4k&t=539s>.
Pandey A., “Was I wrong?” BJP MLA says boycott Muslim vegetable sellers, defiant, “New Delhi Television” [online], 28 IV 2020 [access: 20 III 2021]: <https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/coronavirus-lockdown-on-camera-bjp-mla-suresh-tiwari-says-boycott-muslim-vegetable-vendors-defends-himself-2219589>.
Pandya A.A., Muslim Indians. Struggle for inclusion, The Henry L. Stimson Center, Washington DC 2010: <https://www.stimson.org/wp-content/files/file-attachments/Muslim_Indians-Complete_1.pdf> [access: 27 XI 2020].
Parth M.N., Bengali S., Fake news fuels nationalism and Islamophobia – sound familiar? In this case, it’s in India, “Los Angeles Times” [online], 11 VII 2017 [access: 29 I 2021]: <https://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-india-fake-news-20170711-story.html>.
Pennycook G., Rand D.G., The psychology of fake news, “Trends in Cognitive Sciences” 2021, vol. 25: <https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1364661321000516> [access: 15 V 2021].
Prime Minister’s interview to CNN’s Fareed Zakaria, “Narendra Modi” [online], 21 X 2014 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://www.narendramodi.in/pms-interview-to-cnns-farid-zakaria-2865>.
Report on the inquiry into a working definition of Islamophobia / anti-Muslim hatred, The All Party Parliamentary Group on British Muslims, 2017: <https://static1.squarespace.com/static/599c3d2febbd1a90cffdd8a9/t/5bfd1ea3352f531a6170ceee/1543315109493/Islamophobia+Defined.pdf> [access: 27 III 2021].
Salve P., Manipulative fake news on the rise in India under lockdown: study, “India Spend” [online], 3 V 2020 [access: 29 I 2021]: <https://www.indiaspend.com/manipulative-fake-news-on-the-rise-in-india-under-lockdown-study/>.
Sharma V., BJP on backfoot on migrants issue and “fake” news targeting minorities, “The Tribune” [online], 12 V 2020 [access: 28 III 2021]: <https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/reviews/story/bjp-on-back-foot-on-migrants-issue-and-fake-news-targeting-minorities-83777>.
Stokes B., Manevich D., Chwe H., Three years in, Modi remains very popular. Broad public satisfaction with economy; declining support for U.S., Pew Research Center, 15 XI 2017: <http://www.pewglobal.org/2017/11/15/indiamodi-remains-very-popular-three-years-in/> [access: 15 VI 2020].
Subramanian S., How Hindu supremacists are tearing India apart, “The Guardian” [online], 20 II 2020 [access: 27 XI 2020]: <https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/feb/20/hindu-supremacists-nationalism-tearing-india-apart-modi-bjp-rss-jnu-attacks>.
Tablighi event: Shobha smells “Corona jihad”, “The Hindu” [online], 4 IV 2020 [access: 29 V 2020]: <https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/karnataka/tablighi-event-shobha-smells-corona-jihad/article31259288.ece>.
Tablighi Jamaat is a factory of corona: VHP, “The Siasat Daily” [online], 3 IV 2020 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://www.siasat.com/tablighi-jamaat-factory-corona-vhp-1868672/>.
The interview of PM Narendra Modi with “Time”, “Narendra Modi” [online], 8 V 2015 [access: 15 VI 2020]: <https://www.narendramodi.in/the-interview-of-pm-narendra-modi-with-time-7846>.
Timeline: Ayodhya holy site crisis, “BBC News” [online], 6 XII 2012 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://www.bbc.com/news/world-south-asia-11436552>.
Trivedi D., Targeting a community, “Frontline” [online], 8 V 2020 [access: 15 VI 2020]: <https://frontline.thehindu.com/cover-story/article31374077.ece>.
United Nations Strategy and Plan of Action on Hate Speech, United Nations, September 2020: <https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/documents/UN%20Strategy%20and%20PoA%20on%20Hate%20Speech_Guidance%20on%20Addressing%20in%20field.pdf> [access: 27 I 2021].
Venugopal V., Tąblighi Jamaat is a Talibani crime, not negligence: Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, “The Economic Times” [online], 2 IV 2020 [access: 29 V 2020]: <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/taąblighi-jamaat-is-a-talibani-crime-not-negligence-mukhtar-abbas-naąqvi/articleshow/74940835.cms?from=mdr>.
Vice News, India burning (clip) | Vice on showtime, “You Tube” [online], 1 IV 2020 [access: 27 III 2021]: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCyBL8dBOEo>.
Waterson J., Influencers among “key distributors” of coronavirus misinformation, “The Guardian” [online], 8 IV 2020 [access: 27 I 2021]: <https://www.theguardian.com/media/2020/apr/08/influencers-being-key-distributors-of-coronavirus-fake-news>.
Yasir S., India is scapegoating Muslims for the spread of the coronavirus, “Foreign Policy” [online], 22 IV 2020 [access: 29 V 2020]: <https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/04/22/india-muslims-coronavirus-scapegoat-modi-hindu-nationalism/>.
Zajączkowska N., Hindu-Muslim relations in times of coronavirus, “Studia Orientalne” 2020, nr 2 (18).
Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Użycie niekomercyjne – Na tych samych warunkach 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
Ten utwór jest dostępny na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Użycie niekomercyjne – Na tych samych warunkach 4.0 Międzynarodowe.