Kryzys Yanomami: implikacje epistemologiczne i etyczne


The article presents the history of the research conducted among the Venezuelan Yanomami and the controversies which arose surrounding that research towards the end of the 1980s. This is the greatest controversy in modern anthropology and one of the most serious in the whole history of the discipline. In literature this stormy discussion (which even extends beyond anthropological circles) is known as the “Yanomami crisis”. The author argues that the reasons for the “Yanomami crisis” can be found in earlier sources and are the result of complex interparadigmatic disputes. In addition, he presents criticisms of the work of the first Yanomamologists from the perspective of the anthropological New Criticism and, finally, he discusses the most important consequences of the crisis — both those concerning the way in which the research was carried out, the ethical standards and the way in which the anthropology of culture functions in public discourse.

Albert Bruce, 1989, Yanomami „Violence”: Inclusive Fitness or Ethnographer Representation?, „Current Anthropology”, t. 30, nr 5, s. 637–640.

Albert Bruce, 1990, On Yanomami Warfare: Rejonder, „Current Anthropology”, t. 31, nr 5, s. 558–563.

Asch Timothy, 1991, Foreword, w: Jacques Lizot, Tales of the Yanomami: Daily Life in the Venezuelan Forest, Cambridge Universtity Press, Cambridge, New York.

Barnard Alan, 2006, Antropologia. Zarys teorii i historii, tłum. Sebastian Szymański, PIW, Warszawa.

Blick Jeffrey P., 1988, Genocidal Warfare in Tribal Societes as a Result of European-Induced Culture Conflict, „Man”, New Series, t. 23, nr 4, s. 654–670.

Borgerhoff Mulder Monique, 1987, Progress in Human Sociobiology, „Anthropology Today”, t. 3, nr 1, s. 5–8.

Borofsky Robert, 2005, Yanomami: The Fierce Controversy and What We Can Learn from It, University of California Press, Berkeley–Los Angeles–London.

Bower Bruce, 2001, Rumble in the Jungle, „Science News”, t. 159, nr 4, s. 58–61.

Brown P., 2000, US Scientists Brought Death to the Amazon, „Manchester Guardian Weekly”, 4 października.

Bryman Alan, 2001, The Mead/Freeman Controversy: Some Implications for Qualitative Researchers, w: Alan Bryman (red.), Ethnography, Sage, London.

Carneiro da Cunha Maria Manuela, 1989, Letter to the Editor, „Anthropology Newsletter”, nr 30 (1), s. 3.

Chagnon N. A., [n.d.], Ethnographic and Personal Aspects of Filming and Producing „The Ax Fight”,

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1976, Fission in an Amazonian Tribe: What Determines the Size of Primitive Social Groups?, „The Science”, nr 1–2, s. 14–18.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1983, Yanmomamö: The Fierce People, 3. wyd., Holt, Rinehart and Winston: New York, Chicago, San Francisco.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1988, Life Histories, Blood Revenge, and Warfare in Tribal Population, „Science”, t. 239, nr 4843, s. 985–992.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1989, Response to Ferguson, „American Ethnologist”, t. 16, nr 3, s. 565–570.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1990, On Yanomamo Violence: Reply to Albert, „Current Anthropology”, t. 31, nr 1, s. 49–53.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1995, L’Ethnologie du déshonneur: Brief Response to Lizot, „American Ethnologist”, t. 22, nr 1, s. 187–189.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1996, Review of „Yanomami Warfare: A Political History” by Brian R. Ferguson, „American Anthropologist”, t. 98, nr 3, s. 670–672.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1997a, Yanomamö, 5 wyd., Harcourt Brace College Publishers, Fort Worth–Philadelphia–San Diego.

Chagnon Napoleon A., 1997b, Yanomamö Interactive: The Ax Fight. User’s Manual, Wadsworth, Singapore–Melbourne–Toronto.

Chagnon Napoleon A., Le Quense Philip, Cook James M., 1971, Yanomamo Hallucinogens: Anthropological, Botanical and Chemical Findings, „Current Anthropology”, t. 12, nr 1, s. 72–74.

Coronil Fernando i in., 2001, Perspectives on Tierney’s „Darkness in El Dorado”, w: Current Anthropology Forum on Anthropology in Public, „Current Anthropology”, t. 42, nr 2, s. 265–276.

Daly Martin, Wilson Margo, 1991, Anti-Science and the Pre-Darwinian Image of Mankind, „American Anthropologist”, New Series, t. 93, nr 1, s. 162–165.

Dufour Darna L., 1994, Diet and Nutritional Status of Amazonian Peoples, w: Anna Roosevelt (red.), Amazonian Indians from Prehstory to the Present: Anthropological Perspectives, The University of Arizona Press, Tuscon.

Elliott John, 2000, Scientists „Nearly Destroyed” Amazon Tribe Backed by Sting, „Sunday Times”, 8 października.

Engrácia de Oliveira Adélia E., 1994, The Evidence for the Nature of the Process of Indigenous Deculturation and Destabilization in the Brazilian Amazon in the Last Three Hundred Years, w: Anna Roosevelt (red.), Amazonian Indians from Prehistory to the Present Anthropological Perspectives, The University of Arizona Press, Tuscon.

Feleppa Robert, 1986, Emics, Etics and Social Objectivity, „Current Anthropology”, t. 27, nr 3, s. 243–255.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1988, How Can Anthropologist Promote Peace?, „Anthropology Today”, t. 4, nr 3, s. 1–3.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1989, Do Yanomami Killers Have More Kids?, „American Ethnologist”, t. 16, nr 3, s. 564–565.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1990, Blood of the Leviathan: Western Contact and Warfare in Amazonia, „American Ethnologist”, t. 17, nr 2, s. 237–257.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1992, Yanomami — A Savage Encounter: Western Contact and the Yanomami War Complex, w: R. Brian Ferguson, Neil L. Whitehead (red.), War in the Tribal Zone: Expanding States and Indigenous Warfare, School of American Research Press, Santa Fe.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1995a, Yanomami Warfare: A Political History, School of American Research Press, Santa Fe.

Ferguson R. Brian, 1995b, A Reputation for War, „Natural History”, t. 104, nr 4, s. 62–64.

Ferguson R. Brian, 2001, Materialist, Cultural and Biological Theories on Why Yanomami Make War, „Anthropological Theory”, t. 1, nr 1, s. 99–116.

Fleck Ludwik, 1986, Powstanie i rozwój faktu naukowego, tłum. Maria Tuszkiewicz, Wydawnictwo Lubelskie, Lublin.

Freeman Derek, 1996, Margaret Mead and the Heretic: The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth, Penguin Books–Ringwood, New York.

Freeman Derek, 1999, The Fateful Hoaxing of Margaret Mead: A Historical Analysis of Her Samoan Research, Westview Press, Oxford.

Geertz Clifford, 2001, Life Among the Anthros, „The New York Review of Books”, 8 lutego.

Geertz Clifford, 2003, Wojna kultur, w: Clifford Geertz, Zastane światło. Antropologiczne refleksje na tematy filozoficzne, tłum. Zbigniew Pucek, Universitas, Kraków.

Good Kenneth, 1991, Into the Heart: One Man’s Pursuit of Love and Knowledge among the Yanomami, Simon and Schuster, New York.

Gregory Juno, 2000, Macho Anthropology: Did Scientists Start a Deadly Epidemic to Prove that Humanity Is Innately Violent — Or Are They Victims Of Politics?, „”, 28 września.

Gross Paul R., 2001, Exorcising Sociobiology, „The New Criterion”, t. 19, nr 6.

Hammersley Martyn Atkinson Paul, 2000, Metody badań terenowych, tłum. Sławomir Dymczyk, Zysk i S-ka, Poznań.

Harris Marvin, 1976, History and Significance of the Emic/Etic Distinction, „Annual Review of Anthropology”, t. 5, s. 329–350.

Hern Warren M., 1994, Health and Demography of Native Amazonians: Historical Perspective and Current Status, w: Anna Roosevelt (red.), Amazonian Indians from Prehstory to the Present: Anthropological Perspectives, The Universityof Arizona Press, Tuscon.

Holmes Lowell D., 1988, Quest for Real Samoa: The Mead/Freeman Controversy and Beyond, Bergin and Garvey Publ., South Hadley.

Kirby A., 2000, Amazon Geneticist „Killed Hundreds” , „The Guardian”, 23 września.

Kuhn Thomas, 2001, Struktura rewolucji naukowych, tłum. Helena Ostromęcka, Fundacja Aletheia, Warszawa.

Lizot Jacques, 1977, Population, Resources and Warfare among the Yanomami , „Man”, New Series, t. 12, nr 3/4, s. 497–517.

Lizot Jacques, 1991, Tales of the Yanomami: Daily Life in the Venezuelan Forest, tłum. E. Simon, Cambridge Universtity Press, Cambridge–New York.

Lizot Jacques,1994a, On Warfare: An Answer to N. A. Chagnon, „American Ethnologist”, t. 21, nr 4, s. 845–862.

Lizot Jacques, 1994b, Words in the Night: The Ceremonial Dialogue, One Expression of Peaceful Relationships among the Yanomami, w: Leslie E. Sponsel, Thomas Gregor (red.), The Anthropology of Peace and Nonviolence, Lynne Riener, Boulder.

Lizot Jacques, Barry Ross E., 1979, On Food Taboos and Amazonian Cultural Ecology, „Current Anthropology”, t. 20, nr 1, s. 150–155.

Mann Charles C., 2001, Scientific Community: Anthropological Warfare, „Science”, t. 291, nr 5503, s. 419–421.

Mann Charles C., 2001, Scientific Community: Preemptive Strike Sought to Discredit Book Before It Was Published, „Science”, t. 291, nr 5503, s. 416–418.

Marcus George, Cushman Richard, 1982, Ethnographies as Texts, „Annual Review of Anthropology” t. 11, s. 25–69.

Miller D. W., 2000, Scholars Fear That Alleged Misdeeds by Amazon Anthropologist Will Taint Entire Discipline, „The Chronicle of Higher Education”, 20 września.

Miller John J., 2000, The Fierce People: The Wages of Anthropological Incorrectness, „National Review”, nr 20, s. 45–47.

Moore John H., 1990, The Reproductive Success of Cheyene War Chiefs: A Contrary Case to Chagnon’s Yanomamo, „Current Anthropology”, t. 31, nr 3, s. 322–330.

Morris Michael W. i in., 1999, Views from Inside and Outside: Integrating Emic and Etic Insights about Culture and Justice Judgment, „The Academy of Management Review”, t. 24, nr 4, s. 781–796.

Morton Newton E., 2001, Darkness in El Dorado: Human Genetics on Trial, „Journal of Genetics”, t. 80, nr 1, s. 45–52.

Obeyesekere Gananath, 1997, The Apotheosis of Captain Cook: European Mythmaking in the Pacific, Princeton University Press, New Jersey.

Pike Kenneth L., 1967, Language in Relation to a Unified Theory of the Structures of Human Behavior, Mounton, The Hague.

Ramos Alcida R., 1979, On Women’s Status in Yanoama Societies, „Current Anthropology”, t. 20, nr 1, s. 185–187.

Ramos Alcida R., 1991, Urihi. Report no. 13,

Ramos Alcida R., 1999, Rozmyślając o Yanomami: wyobrażenia etnograficzne a pogoń za egzotyką, tłum. Wojciech Dochnal, w: Michał Buchowski, Marian Kempny (red.), Amerykańska antropologia postmodernistyczna, Instytut Kultury, Warszawa.

Robarchek Clayton A., 1989, Primitive Warfare and the Ratomorphic Image of Mankind, „American Anthropologist”, New Series, t. 91, nr 4, s. 903–920.

Roosevelt M., 2000, What Have We Done to Them?, „Time Magazine”, t. 156, nr 14.

Sahlins Marshall D., 1995, How „Natives” Think: about Captain Cook, for Example, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago–London.

Sahlins Marshall D., 2000, Review of: „Darkness in El Dorado…”, „The Washington Post”, Book World, s. X01.

Seattle Times, 2000, Scientists Deliberately Infected Tribe with Measles, „The Seattle Times”, 29 września, s. A13.

Shermer Michael, 2001, The Erotic-fierce People: The Latest Skirmish in the „Anthropology wars” Reveals Flaw in How Science is Understood and Communicated, „Scientific American”, 284:5, s. 31.

Sponsel Leslie E., 1990, Ultraprimitive Pacifists: The Tasaday as a Symbol of Peace, „Anthropology Today”, t. 6, nr 1, s. 3–5.

Sponsel Leslie E., 1998, Yanomami: An Arena of Conflict and Aggression in the Amazon, „Aggressive Behavious”, t. 24, s. 97–122.

Sponsel Leslie E., Turner Terence S., 2000, email: „Scandal about to be caused by publication of book by Patrick Tierney (Darkness in El Dorado. New York. Norton”, opublikowany 1 października 2000,

Steel Daniel, 1998, Warfare and Western Manufactures: A Case Study of Explanation in Anthropology, „Philosophy of Science”, t. 65, nr 4, s. 649–671.

Survival Press Release, 2000, US Scientists Accused of Conducting Nazi Experiments on Amazonian Indians — Hundreds Killed, Survival Press Release, wrzesień.

Szymborski Krzysztof, 2000, Ludobójstwo w celach poznawczych, „Magazyn Gazety Wyborczej”, nr 49, grudzień, s. 42.

Tierney Patrick, 2000, A Reporter at Large: The Fierce Anthropologist, „New Yorker”, 9 października, s. 50–61.

Tierney Patrick, 2001, Darkness in El Dorado: How Scientists and Journalist Devastated the Amazon, W. W. Norton, London–New York.

Tiffany Sharon W., Adams Kathleen J., 1994, Anthropology’s „Fierce” Yanomami: Narratives of Sexual Politics in the Amazon, „National Women’s Studies Association Journal”, t. 6, nr 2, s. 169–196.

Tiffany S. W., Adams K. J., 1996, Housewives of the Forest: Representation in Ethnographic Film, „Women’s Studies”, t. 25, s. 169–186.

Turner Terence S., 2001, In response to „Life Among The Anthros”, „New York Review of Books”, t. 48, nr 7.

Walczak Bartłomiej, 2006, Czwarta wyprawa kapitana Cooka, w: Joanna Tokarska-Bakir (red.), Cóż po antropologii?, Collegium Civitas, Warszawa.


Opublikowane : 2007-12-19

Walczak, B. (2007). Kryzys Yanomami: implikacje epistemologiczne i etyczne. Kultura I Społeczeństwo, 51(4), 3-33.

Bartłomiej Walczak
Wyższa Szkoła Pedagogiki ResocjalizacyjneJ Pedagogium; Uniwersytet Warszawski  Polska