Vol. 75 No. 2 (2022): Dezinformacja i operacje wpływu
Bezpieczeństwo Europy Środkowej i Wschodniej
Russia – full spectrum revisionist? What the Kremlin’s exploitation of the Belarusian political crisis teaches us about the nature of Russia’s confrontation with the West
Abstract
The political crisis in Belarus, provoked by public dissatisfaction with the fraudulent presidential election in August 2020, has entailed a number of consequences for the international status of Belarus. On the one hand, there was a rapprochement with Russia and, on the other, Belarus found itself in a state of cold war with the West. The reasons for this state of affairs should be seen primarily in the attitude of Alyaksandr Lukashenka, who perceived the social protests as a serious threat to his illegitimate rule and, at the same time, inspired by the West. The threat of losing power caused him to turn to Russia for help, which was given to him. Russia was guided primarily in this case by its own fears, which concerned: the threat of losing control over a geopolitically important region, the shrinking of the area considered to be a zone of exclusive interests in favour of the West, the prospects of the successful democratisation of Belarus and the transmission of the virus of democracy to the Russian political system. Lukashenka, still unsure of his position and Russia’s support, has taken steps to strengthen the Kremlin’s loyalty. To this end, he continued to take anti-Western actions, aware that his closest ally in the Kremlin was the siloviks group, which was the most influential group of the Kremlin’s elite and at the same time responsible for the Russian confrontation with the West. From Russia’s point of view, the Belarus-Russia conflict has become a platform for a whole spectrum of revisionist activities: offensive, defensive and isolationist. At the same time, Belarus and its conflict with the West have become part of information warfare against the West, as a part of which the Kremlin was generating tension in the capitals of European countries and the United States. Russia was interested in keeping this going as long as possible, which was not necessarily in line with Lukashenka’s own expectations. Whether he liked it or not, he has become a hostage to the fraternal grip of help from Russia. Even if Lukashenka was overwhelmed with help from Russia, whose hug was suffocating for Belarus’ autonomy, the benefits from playing with Russia in one team were greater than the costs of rejecting the Kremlin’s friendship... at least until 24 February 2022.
References
- Astapenia R., Why the Belarusian revolution has stalled, “Chatham House” [online], 9 II 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.chathamhouse.org/2021/02/why-belarusian-revolution-has-stalled>.
- Badûk A., “Putin otvlekaet vnimanie ot Kryma”: začem Rossiâ stâgivaet svoû armiû k granicam Ukrainy, “Krym. Realii” [online], 17 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://ru.krymr.com/a/armiya-rossii-vozle-granits-ukrainy-krym/31565507.html?fbclid=iwar3u1vftxqhw5c69yyyjwjabhri7ua9kk_pyr7cudfxjcz8rzxkos-8cp-a>.
- Baklitskiy A. A., Putin’s demand for security guarantees: Not new and not to be taken literally, but not to be ignored, “Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists” [online], 14 I 2022 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://thebulletin.org/2022/01/putins-demand-for-security-guarantees-not-new-and-not-to-be-taken-literally-but-not-to-be-ignored/>.
- Belarus, Russia and the union state, “Russian Public Opinion Research Center Press Release” [online], 9 VII 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://wciom.com/index.php?id=61&uid=1794>.
- Dorohov V., Volkov D., Glava “Levada-Centra”: Obŝee otnošenie rossiân k sankciâm – Zapad protiv nas, “Levada-Centr” [online], 16 VI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.levada.ru/2021/06/10/glava-levada-tsentra-obshhee-otnoshenie-rossiyan-k-sanktsiyam-zapad-protiv-nas/?fbclid=iwar3v-cmblk7lhctthacu2evzfepi-cbzpntehhh6ias7ix58f685ujvt86u>.
- Dyner A. M., Belarus and Russia. Accelerated integration, The Polish Institute of International Affairs, [Warsaw] 30 VI 2021 (Bulletin, 125 (1821)).
- Eckle M., Pentagon chief calls Russia, China “revisionist powers”, “Radio Free Europe. Radio Liberty” [online], 19 I 2018 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.rferl.org/a/pentagon-mattis-calls-russia-china-revisionist-powers/28985632.html>.
- Exclusive: Liz Truss tells Vladimir Putin to end “shameful” migrant crisis, “The Telegraph” [online], 13 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2021/11/13/exclusive-liz-truss-tells-vladimir-putin-end-shameful-migrant/>.
- Èksperty: Real′nye celi Kremlâ mogut okazat′sâ daleko ne stol′ vdohnovlâûŝimi dlâ belorusskogo režima, “Ex-Press” [online], 16 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://ex-press.by/rubrics/politika/2021/11/16/eksperty-realnye-celi-kremlya-mogut-okazatsya-daleko-ne-stol-vdoxnovlyayushhimi-dlya-belorusskogo-rezhima>.
- Fedorov A., Gotov li Kreml′ vzât′ na sebâ otvetstvennost′ za vsё, čto proizojdet v Belarusi?, “Ex-Press” [online], 18 x 2020 [accessed: 4 iii 2022]: <https://ex-press.by/rubrics/politika/2020/10/18/gotov-li-kreml-vzyat-na-sebya-otvetstvennost-za-vsyo-chto-proizojdet-v-belarusi>.
- Felgenhauer P., Russian troops deploy to Belarus with fanfare, “Eurasia Daily Monitor” 2022, vol. 19, issue 3: <https://jamestown.org/program/russian-troops-deploy-to-belarus-with-fanfare/?fbclid=iwar0uwkgjmeaocgd8cfgeajg5itb7mtodzmt6rimnkansa854ndnnc_zwcz0> [accessed: 4 III 2022].
- Frolova N., «Kolhoznik», «prihvostni» i «mladšie brat′â». Kak propaganda Kremlâ podaёt situaciû v Belarusi, “Lietuvos nacionalinis radijas ir televizija” [online], 30 VII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.lrt.lt/ru/novosti/17/1460053/kolkhoznik-prikhvostni-i-mladshie-brat-ia-kak-propaganda-kremlia-podaiot-situatsiiu-v-belarusi>.
- Götz E., Merlen C.-R., Russia and the question of world order, “European Politics and Society” 2019, vol. 20, No. 2.
- Gromova A., Putin rasskazal, kak Evropa delila Rossiû na neskol′ko stran v 90-e, “Gazeta” [online], 12 XII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.gazeta.ru/politics/2021/12/12_a_14307259.shtml?updated>.
- Hodasevič A., Protivniki Lukašenko hotât dostučat′sâ do Kremlâ, “Nezavisimaâ gazeta”, 7 X 2020.
- Howlett D., The future of strategic culture, Defense Threat Reduction Agency Advanced Systems and Concepts Office, 31 X 2006: <https://irp.fas.org/agency/dod/dtra/stratcult-future.pdf> [accessed: 4 III 2022].
- Ikenberry G. J., The end of liberal international order?, “International Affairs” 2018, vol. 94, No. 1.
- Ivanov S. N., Na zaŝite interesov soûznogo gosudarstva, “Služby vnešnej razvedki Rossijskoj Federacii” [online], 3 VI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <http://svr.gov.ru/smi/2021/06/na-zashchite-interesov-soyuznogo-gosudarstva.htm>.
- Karl T. L., Schmitter Ph., Models of transition in Latin America, Southern and Eastern Europe, “International Social Science Journal” 1991, vol. 43, No. 128.
- Kazharski A., Kubová M., Belarus as a liminal space for Russia’s ontological security before and after the 2020 protests, “New Perspectives” 2021, vol. 29, No. 3.
- Klinke I., Geopolitical narratives on Belarus in contemporary Russia, “Perspectives” 2008, vol. 16, No. 1.
- Kreml′ dobivaetsâ priznaniâ Lukašenko prezidentom? Čem migrantskij krizis pohož na vojnu v Ukraine, “Radìo Svoboda” [online], 11 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/migranty-putin-lukashenko/31556390.html>.
- Kuleba: “migranty Lukašenko”, dorogoj gaz i manevry vokrug Ukrainy – čast′ gibridnoj vojny rf, “Evropejskaâ pravda” [online], 15 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/rus/news/2021/11/15/7130293/>.
- Lavrov: es primenâet dvojnye standarty v situacii s migrantami na granice Pol′ši, “TASS” [online], 16 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://tass.ru/politika/12938015>.
- Lavrov prizval Zapad prekratit′ demonizirovat′ Belorussiû iz-za incidenta s Ryanair, “TASS” [online], 27 V 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://tass.ru/politika/11492163>.
- Lavrov: rukovodstvo Belorussii priznaet, čto vybory ne byli ideal′nymi, “Gazeta” [online], 19 VIII 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.gazeta.ru/politics/news/2020/08/19/n_14819515.shtml>.
- Levčenko I., Belaruskaâ ugroza. Stanet li Lukašenko instrumentom agressii Rossii, “Belarus Security Blog” [online], 8 XII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://bsblog.info/belaruskaya-ugroza-stanet-li-lukashenko-instrumentom-agressii-rossii/>.
- Levinson A., Pust′ Aleksandr Lukašenko pravit, “v Times” [online], 3 XI 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.vtimes.io/2020/11/03/pochemu-belorussiya-ne-pohozha-na-rossiyu-a1245>.
- Levinson A., Rossiâ bez Belorussii, “Vedomosti”, 20 i 2020.
- Luk′ânov F., Čto nado sdelat′ Moskve, čtoby privâzannost′ k nej Belorussii ne zavisela ot Lukašenko, “Profil′” [online], 10 VIII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://profile.ru/abroad/chto-nado-sdelat-moskve-chtoby-privyazannost-k-nej-belorussii-ne-zavisela-ot-lukashenko-907191/>.
- Lukašenko rasskazal o gotovivšemsâ pokušenii na nego i ego synovej, “Izvestiâ” [online], 17 IV 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://iz.ru/1153046/2021-04-17/lukashenko-rasskazal-o-zaderzhanii-planirovavshei-pokushenie-na-ego-detei-gruppy?fbclid=iwar2girim1xp0uoi9_vjncrzniupbjfbdu3ccbz7_mv6pwsg_bnivlab7_4k>.
- Lukašenko zaâvil o planah obsudit′ s Putinym dal′nejšie šagi sovmestnoj gruppirovki vojsk, “TASS” [online], 17 II 2022 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/13738109?fbclid=iwar30nwbaegjs6mjl6tsajrw4z7a9cns1_hcgs-r2pnrlrwlzl1nqmper7ri>.
- Luzin P., Military integration of the Union State, “Riddle Russia” [online], 20 II 2022 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://ridl.io/en/military-integration-of-the-union-state/?fbclid=iwar1vxa2jnha3fwvsoufodtptukol90rkc7quvub6ab6slo2bu7lsonijlzi>.
- Macfarlane S. N., The “R” in BRICS. Is Russia an emerging power?, “International Affairs” 2006, vol. 82, No. 1.
- Makej i Borrel′ obsudili situaciû na granice Belorussii i es, “TASS” [online], 16 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://tass.ru/mezhdunarodnaya-panorama/12943307>.
- Minsk delaet vse, čto ot nego zavisit, v svâzi s migracionnym krizisom, situaciû nado depolitizirovat′, “Interfaks – AVN” [online], 5 XII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.militarynews.ru/story.asp?rid=1&nid=561734&lang=ru%d1%82>.
- Mirovalev M., How Russian media is trying to save Lukashenko’s Belarus, “Al Jazeera” [online], 12 IX 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/9/18/how-russian-media-is-trying-to-save-lukashenkos-belarus>.
- Mnogie gosudarstvennye smi v Rossii ne spešat podderživat′ Aleksandra Lukašenko. Polučaetsâ, Kreml′ bol′še v nego ne verit?, “Meduza” [online], 19 VIII 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://meduza.io/feature/2020/08/19/mnogie-gosudarstvennye-smi-v-rossii-ne-speshat-podderzhivat-aleksandra-lukashenko-poluchaetsya-kreml-bolshe-v-nego-ne-verit>.
- Moshes A., Nizhnikau R., The Belarusian revolution: Sources, interim outcomes, and lessons to be learned, “Demokratizatsiya: The journal of post-Soviet democratization” 2021, vol. 29, No. 2.
- Mudrov S. A., Doomed to fail? Why success was almost not an option in the 2020 protests in Belarus, “Journal of Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe” 2021, vol. 29, issue 1.
- Naryškin zaâvil o stremlenii nekonstitucionnymi metodami smenit′ vlast′ v Belorussii, “Izvestiâ” [online], 22 X 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://iz.ru/1077206/2020-10-22/naryshkin-zaiavil-o-stremlenii-nekonstitutcionnymi-metodami-smenit-vlast-v-belorussii>.
- Nikolûk S., Čtoby slučilis′ izmeneniâ, dolžen proizojti ne raskol, a spločenie èlit, “Svobodnye novosti plûs” [online], 6 IV 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.sn-plus.com/2021/04/06/chtoby-sluchilis-izmeneniya-dolzhen-proizojti-ne-raskol-a-splochenie-elit/>.
- Pastuhov V., Revolûciâ othodit s Belorusskogo vokzala, “Novaâ gazeta”, 18 ix 2020.
- Percev A., Lysova T., Rustamova F., Putin podderživaet Lukašenko? Kreml′ rešil, čto delat′ s Belarus′û? Spojler: kažetsâ, nikakogo plana u Moskvy net, “Meduza” [online], 19 IX 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://meduza.io/feature/2020/09/19/putin-podderzhivaet-lukashenko-kreml-reshil-chto-delat-s-belarusyu>.
- Peskov: Rossiâ podderživaet ne Lukašenko, a zakonnost′ v Belorussii, “EA Daily” [online], 13 xi 2020 [accessed: 4 ii 2022]: <https://eadaily.com/ru/ampnews/2020/11/13/peskov-rossiya-podderzhivaet-ne-lukashenko-a-zakonnost-v-belorussii>.
- Petrov G., Rossiâ zagovorit na âzyke “krasnyh linij”, “Nezavisimaâ gazeta”, 18 XI 2021.
- Popytka gosperevorota v Belarusi / Operaciâ «Tišina» / Rabota specslužb. Ponâtnaâ politika plûs, “You Tube. atn: novosti Belarusi i mira” [online], 21 IV 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tu7lbn9fnfy&feature=youtu.be>.
- Prejgerman E., Na čestnom slove i odnom kryle, “Minsk Dialogue” [online], 4 IX 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://minskdialogue.by/research/opinions/na-chestnom-slove-i-odnom-kryle>.
- Prezident Rossii V. V. Putin otvetil na voprosy žurnalista telekanala «Rossiâ 1» Pavla Zarubina, 13 noâbrâ 2021 goda, “Posol′stvo Rossijskoj Federacii v Soedinennom Korolevstve Velikobritanii i Severnoj Irlandii” [online], 13 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.rus.rusemb.org.uk/fnapr/6009>.
- Putin otmetil otsutstvie reakcii Zapada na predotvraŝennoe pokušenie na Lukašenko, “Interfaks” [online], 21 IV 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.interfax.ru/world/762463>.
- Putin priznal legitimnost′ prezidentskih vyborov v Belorussii, “ria Novosti” [online], 29 VIII 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://ria.ru/20200829/vybory-1576464111.html>.
- Putin raskritikoval Pol′šu za dejstviâ silovikov na granice, “Regnum” [online], 18 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 iii 2022]: <https://regnum.ru/news/polit/3426926.html>.
- Rossiâ i Belarus′ zaâvili o predotvraŝenii perevorota i pokušeniâ na Lukašenko. Ih âkoby
- planirovali na 9 maâ, “bbc News” [online], 17 IV 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.bbc.com/russian/news-56770162>.
- Rumer E., Sokolsky R., Etched in stone: Russian strategic culture and the future of transatlantic security, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Washington 2020: <https://carnegieendowment.org/files/Russian_Strategic_Culture_Rumer_Sokolsky.pdf> [accessed: 4 III 2022].
- Russia in the changing international system, ed. E. P. Dal, E. Ersen, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham, Switzerland 2019.
- Russia’s proposal to redraw European security “unacceptable,” U.S. says, “Radio Free Europe. Radio Liberty” [online], 17 XII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.rferl.org/a/nato-russia-security-guarantees/31614168.html>.
- Sahnin A., V Belorussii ošiblis′ vse, “Vedomosti” [online], 9 II 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.vedomosti.ru/opinion/articles/2021/02/08/857158-belorussii-oshiblis>.
- Sakwa R., Stasis and change: Russia and the emergence of an anti-hegemonic world order, [in:] Russia in the changing international system, ed. E. P. Dal, E. Ersen, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham, Switzerland 2019.
- Sivickij A., Belarus′: ot donorstva stabil′nosti i bezopasnosti k «èskalacii dlâ deèskalacii». V čem strategičeskij rasčet i prosčet Minska?, “Belarus Security Blog” [online], 9 IX 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://bsblog.info/belarus-ot-donorstva-stabilnosti-i-bezopasnosti-k-eskalacii-dlya-deeskalacii-v-chem-strategicheskij-raschet-i-proschet-minska/>.
- Socor V., A Belarusian revolution? What kind? (part one), “Eurasia Daily Monitor” 2020, vol. 17, issue 154: <https://jamestown.org/program/a-belarusian-revolution-what-kind-part-one/> [accessed: 4 III 2022].
- Sokolov M., Strana Putina, režim Patruševa, “Levada-Centr” [online], 12 VII 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.levada.ru/2021/07/13/strana-putina-rezhim-patrusheva/>.
- Spatkaj L., “Soûznaâ rešimost′-2022”: strategičeskie učeniâ ili podgotovka k vtorženiû v Ukrainu?, “Belarus Security Blog” [online], 2 II 2022 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://bsblog.info/soyuznaya-reshimost-2022-strategicheskie-ucheniya-ili-podgotovka-k-vtorzheniyu-v-ukrainu/>.
- Sushentsov A., Russia – a global revisionist?, “Valdai Discussion Club” [online], 12 vi 2019 [accessed: 4 iii 2022]: <https://valdaiclub.com/a/highlights/russia-a-global-revisionist/>.
- Svetlana Tihanovskaâ – Tuzy, “Èho Moskvy” [online], 26 X 2021 [accessed: 14 II 2022]: <https://echo.msk.ru/programs/tuz/2925800-echo/>.
- Šojgu: popytka smeny vlasti v Belorussii byla predprinâta pri podderžke Zapada, “Zvezda” [online], 27 X 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://tvzvezda.ru/news/forces/content/20201027117-ri5sr.html?utm_source=tvzvezda&utm_medium=longpage&utm_campaign=longpage&utm_term=v1>.
- Šrajbman A., Budet li Kreml′ vmešivat′sâ v belorusskij migracionnyj krizis?, “Media--Polesye” [online], 8 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://media-polesye.by/news/budet-li-kreml-vmeshivatsya-v-belorusskij-migraczionnyj-krizis/>.
- Tilly C., From mobilization to revolution, Random House, New York 1978.
- “Verim delam, a ne slovam”. Nikolaj Patrušev – o perspektivah dialoga s sša, “Argumenty i fakty”, 5 V 2021.
- Vladislav Surkov razvel demokratiû na suverennuû i upravlâemuû, “Kommersant″”, 29 VI 2006.
- Wiltenburg I., The importance of understanding Russian strategic culture, “Atlantisch Perspectief” 2020, vol. 44, No. 1.
- Zaharova M., [Glava mid Britanii Liz Trass zaâvila: «Rossiâ nesёt zdes′ čёtkuû otvetstvennost′…], “Telegram” [online], 14 XI 2021 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://t.me/MariaVladimirovnaZakharova/1302>.
- Zatulin vydal “vzglâd Kremlâ” na protesty v Belorussii, “Moskovskij Komsomolec” [online], 13 VIII 2020 [accessed: 4 III 2022]: <https://www.mk.ru/politics/2020/08/13/zatulin-vydal-vzglyad-kremlya-na-protesty-v-belorussii.html>.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.