Strach w obliczu wojny w Ukrainie: osobiste i geopolityczne obawy młodych Polek i Polaków
Abstrakt
Russia’s attack on Ukraine has acutely affected the experiences of Polish women and men and has translated into a sense of living in constant danger in a society of risk and fear. Young people who have not yet achieved stability and are less socially anchored, are particularly vulnerable to fear, anxiety, economic degradation and a loss of ontological security. In this context, the article uses quantitative and qualitative data from the ULTAGEN project focusing on entry into adulthood in times of crisis to map the personal and geopolitical concerns of young Polish women and men. Data from a representative CAWI survey (N = 2104), conducted in January 2023 among 18–35 year olds, showed that almost a year after the war broke out, the vast majority of them were still anxious about the future. Their concerns were primarily about the cumulative consequences of the war: the economic and energy crises, and deteriorating access to public services and the housing market. The respondents also continued to fear a Russian attack on Poland. The qualitative material in turn, collected using the asynchronous exchange technique in March and April 2022 as part of a qualitative longitudinal study, deepens the above findings with detailed analyses focused on two main axes. First of all, the empirical material shows fear of the political enemy, manifested in fears of the war spilling over, a total war, alongside a cumulative refugee-economic crisis, which the interviewees believed threaten national security. Secondly, at the individual level, fear is closely linked to the vision of a “threatened future”, with young people preaching doom and gloom. From a micro-sociological perspective, the narratives illustrate a constant uncertainty and danger. The findings of the mixed-methods research are interpreted through the prism of the sociology of fear and youth studies.
Słowa kluczowe
Ukraina; Polska; wojna; strach; niepewność; młodzi dorośli
Bibliografia
Abbasi Kamran, 2022, Climate, Pandemic, and War: An Uncontrolled Multicrisis of Existential Proportions, „BMJ (Clinical Research Ed.)”, 376: o689.
Barbalet Jack M., 1998, Emotion, Social Theory, and Social Structure: A Macrosociological Approach, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Barchielli Benedetta i in., 2022, Climate Changes, Natural Resources Depletion, COVID-19 Pandemic, and Russian-Ukrainian War: What Is the Impact on Habits Change and Mental Health?, „International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health”, t. 19(19), 11929.
Bauman Zygmunt, 2008, Płynny lęk, tłum. Janusz Margański, Wydawnictwo Literackie, Kraków.
Bauman Zygmunt, 2012, Straty uboczne. Nierówności społeczne w epoce globalizacji, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, Kraków.
Beck Ulrich, 2002, Społeczeństwo ryzyka: w drodze do innej nowoczesności, tłum. Stanisław Cieśla, Scholar, Warszawa.
Beck Ulrich, Beck-Gernsheim Elisabeth, 2009, Global Generations and the Trap of Methodological Nationalism for a Cosmopolitan Turn in the Sociology of Youth and Generation, „European Sociological Review”, t. 25(1), s. 25–36.
Bericat Eduardo, 2016, The Sociology of Emotions: Four Decades of Progress, „Current Sociology”, t. 64(3), s. 491–513.
Bude Heinz, 2018, Society of Fear, Polity, Cambridge.
Burkitt Ian, 2002, Complex Emotions: Relations, Feelings and Images in Emotional Experience, „The Sociological Review”, t. 50(S2), s. 151–167.
Carta Mauro Giovanni, Orrù Germano, Barberini Luigi, 2022, War and Pandemic: A Negative Synergism Could Amplify the Catastrophe, „Journal of Public Health Research”, t. 11(2): 3016.
Colombo Enzo, Rebughini Paola, 2019, A Complex Uncertainty: Young People in the Riddle of the Present, w: Enzo Colombo, Paola Rebughini (red.), Youth and the Politics of the Present. Coping with Complexity and Ambivalence, Routledge, London–New York, s. 1–16.
Duszczyk Maciej, Kaczmarczyk Paweł, 2022, War and Migration: The Recent Influx from Ukraine into Poland and Possible Scenarios for the Future, „CMR Spotlight”, nr 4(39).
Flam Helena, 1998, Mosaic of Fear: Poland and East Germany before 1989, „East European Monographs”, nr 508.
Fothergill Alice, 1996, Gender, Risk, and Disaster, „International Journal of Mass Emergencies & Disasters”, t. 14(1), s. 33–56.
Furedi Frank, 2007, Culture of Fear: Risk Taking and the Morality of Low Expectation, Continuum, London–New York.
Furlong Andy, Cartmel Fred, 2006, Young People and Social Change, McGraw-Hill Education, London.
Geldens Paula M., Bourke Lisa, 2008, Identity, Uncertainty and Responsibility: Privileging Place in a Risk Society, „Children’s Geographies”, t. 6(3), s. 281–294.
Giddens Anthony, 2001, Nowoczesność i tożsamość. „Ja” i społeczeństwo w epoce późnej nowoczesności, tłum. Alina Szulżycka, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, Warszawa.
Giroux Henry A., 2003, The Abandoned Generation: Democracy beyond the Culture of Fear, Palgrave Macmillan.
Green Eileen, Mitchell Wendy, Bunton Robin, 2000, Contextualizing Risk and Danger: An Analysis of Young People’s Perceptions of Risk, „Journal of Youth Studies”, t. 3(2), s. 109–126.
Hafstad Gertrud Sofie, Augusti Else-Marie, 2021, A Lost Generation? COVID-19 and Adolescent Mental Health, „The Lancet Psychiatry”, t. 8(8), s. 640–641.
Hodkinson Phil, Hodkinson Heather, Sparkes Andrew C., 2013, Triumphs and Tears: Young People, Markets, and The Transition from School to Work, Routledge, London.
Hoffmann Stanley, 2004, Thoughts on Fear in Global Society, „Social Research: An International Quarterly”, t. 71(4), s. 1023–1036.
Kajta Justyna, Pustulka Paula, Radzińska Jowita, 2022, Young People and Housing Transitions during COVID-19: Navigating Co-Residence with Parents and Housing Autonomy, „Housing Studies”, t. 38(1), s. 44–64.
Kemper Theodore D., 1978, Toward a Sociology of Emotions: Some Problems and Some Solutions, „The American Sociologist”, t. 13(1), s. 30–41.
Khoo Shuna Shiann, Toh Wei Xing, Yang Hwajin, 2021, Seeking Control during Uncontrollable Times: Control Abilities and Religiosity Predict Stress during COVID-19, „Personality and Individual Differences”, nr 175, s. 110675.
Konecki Krzysztof T., 2022, Empathy! So What?, „Przegląd Socjologii Jakościowej”, t. 18, nr 4, s. 194–233.
Kossowska, Małgorzata, Szwed Paulina, Szumowska Ewa, Perek-Białas Jolanta, Czernatowicz-Kukuczka Aneta, 2023, The Role of Fear, Closeness, and Norms in Shaping Help towards War Refugees, „Scientific Reports”, t. 13(1): 1465 (https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-28249-0).
LeDoux Joseph E., 2000, Mózg emocjonalny: tajemnicze podstawy życia emocjonalnego, tłum. Andrzej Jankowski, Media Rodzina, Poznań.
Lewtak Katarzyna, Kanecki Krzysztof, Tyszko Piotr, Goryński Paweł, Bogdan Magdalena, Nitsch-Osuch Aneta, 2022, Ukraine War Refugees — Threats and New Challenges for Healthcare in Poland, „Journal of Hospital Infection”, nr 125, s. 37–43 (doi: 10.1016/j.jhin.2022.04.006).
Liadze Iana, Macchiarelli Corrado, Mortimer-Lee Paul, Sanchez Juanino Patricia, 2023,
Economic Costs of the Russia-Ukraine War, „The World Economy”, t. 46(4), s. 874–886.
Maciejewska-Mieszkowska Katarzyna, 2022, Stosunek Polaków do uchodźców w kontekście wojny w Ukrainie, „Środkowoeuropejskie Studia Polityczne”, nr 4, s. 137–153.
Mason Jennifer, 2006, Six Strategies for Mixing Methods and Linking Data in Social Science Research, Working Paper Series 4/06, ESRC National Centre for Research Methods NCRM.
Michta Andrew, 2022, Quo Vadis Europe? The “Russian Question”, „Orbis”, t. 66(2), s. 201–212.
Moralli Melissa, Allegrini Giulia, 2021, Crises Redefined: Towards New Spaces for Social Innovation in Inner Areas?, „European Societies”, t. 23(sup1), s. 831–843.
Moshagen Morten, Hilbig Benjamin, 2022, Citizens’ Psychological Reactions Following the Russian Invasion of the Ukraine: A Cross-National Study (doi: 10.31234/osf.io/teh8y).
Neale Bren, 2019, What Is Qualitative Longitudinal Research?, Bloomsbury Publishing, London.
Pargament Kenneth I., 2002, The Bitter and the Sweet: An Evaluation of the Costs and Benefits of Religiousness, „Psychological Inquiry”, t. 13(3), s. 168–181.
Pustulka Paula, Radzińska Jowita, Kajta Justyna, Sarnowska Justyna, Kwiatkowska Agnieszka, Golińska Agnieszka, 2021, Transitions to Adulthood during COVID-19: Background and Early Findings from the ULTRAGEN Project, „Youth Working Papers”, nr 4, SWPS University–Youth Research Center, Warszawa (doi: 10.23809/14).
Pustułka Paula, Kajta Justyna, 2023, Working Lives during the Pandemic. Qualitative Evidence on Coping among Young and Older Workers in Poland, „Polish Sociological Review”, nr 2, s. 211–230.
Pustulka Paula, Kajta Justyna, Kwiatkowska Agnieszka, Sarnowska Justyna, Radzińska Jowita, Golińska Agnieszka, w druku, Settling into Uncertainty and Risk Amidst a Multi-crisis of the COVID-19 Pandemic and the War in Ukraine,
Radzińska Jowita, 2022a, Zmiana postrzegania i doświadczania solidarności w pandemii COVID-19, „Studia Socjologiczne”, nr 3 , s. 111–136.
Radzińska Jowita, 2022b, Między elastycznością a spójnością: wykorzystanie metod asynchronicznych w jakościowym badaniu podłużnym realizowanym w trakcie pandemii, „Przegląd Socjologii Jakościowej”, t. 18, nr 3, s. 10–31.
Radzińska Jowita, Golińska Agnieszka, 2023, Cokolwiek się nie wydarzy mieć odwagę i honor w każdej sytuacji zachować się po prostu przyzwoicie… Granice gościnności na przykładzie przyjęcia w Polsce osób uchodźczych z Ukrainy, „Studia Migracyjne — Przegląd Polonijny” (w druku).
Sarnowska, Justyna, Winogrodzka Dominika, Pustułka Paula, 2018, The Changing Meanings of Work among University-Educated Young Adults from a Temporal Perspective, „Przegląd Socjologiczny”, t. 67, nr 3, s. 111–134.
Shklar Judith N., 1998, Political Thought and Political Thinkers, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Szafraniec Krystyna, 2012, Młodość jako wyłaniający się problem i nowa polityczna siła, „Nauka”, nr 1, s. 101–122.
Tateo Luca, Marsico Giuseppina, Valsiner Jaan, 2022, The Pandemic Atmos-fear, „International Perspectives in Psychology”, t. 11(2), s. 125–133.
Teddlie Charles, Tashakkori Abbas, 2012, Common “Core” Characteristics of Mixed Methods Research: A Review of Critical Issues and Call for Greater Convergence, „American Behavioral Scientist”, t. 56(6), s. 774–788.
Thew Harriet, Middlemiss Lucie, Paavola Jouni, 2020, “Youth Is Not a Political Position”: Exploring Justice Claims-making in the UN Climate Change Negotiations, „Global Environmental Change”, t. 61: 102036.
Thomson Rachel, Bell Robert, Holland Janet, Henderson Sheila, McGrellis Sheena, Sharpe Sue, 2002, Critical Moments: Choice, Chance and Opportunity in Young People’s Narratives of Transition, „Sociology”, t. 36(2), s. 335–354.
Trojanek Radosław, Głuszak Michał, 2022, The War in Ukraine, Refugees, and the Housing Market in Poland, SSNR (https://ssrn.com/abstract=4086551).
Trope Yaacov, Liberman Nira, 2010, Construal-level Theory of Psychological Distance, „Psychological Review, t. 117(2), s. 440–463.
Tudor Andrew, 2003, A (Macro)sociology of Fear?, „The Sociological Review”, t. 51(2), s. 238–256.
Turner Jonathan H., 2010, The Stratification of Emotions: Some Preliminary Generalizations, „Sociological Inquiry”, t. 80(2), s. 168–199.
Turner Jonathan H., Stets Jan E., 2006, Sociological Theories of Human Emotions, „Annual Review of Sociology”, t. 32, s. 25–52.
Turner Jonathan H., Stets Jan E., 2009, Socjologia emocji, tłum. Marta Bucholc, Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN, Warszawa.
ULTRAGEN 2023, zbiór danych z badania CAWI (IPSOS, 2–12.01.2023), A. Kwiatkowska, P. Pustułka, J. Kajta, A. Golińska, J. Radzińska, J. Sarnowska, Uniwersytet SWPS, Warszawa.
Villarreal Ana, 2022, The Logistics of Fear: Violence and The Stratifying Power of Emotion, „Emotions and Society”, t. 4(3), s. 290–306.
Uniwersytet SWPS Polska
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6187-636X
Ten utwór jest dostępny na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa-Użycie niekomercyjne-Na tych samych warunkach 4.0 Międzynarodowe.
