Abstract
This article examines the multifaceted experiences of Polish Muslims as they navigate belonging within both offline and online environments. Using data from a survey and semi-structured interviews, the study illustrates how issues of trust, religious identity, and social exclusion intersect in a predominantly Catholic society. The findings show that widespread skepticism toward Islam and negative media portrayals contribute to Polish Muslims’ heightened sense of caution and lower level of general trust in comparison to the broader population. Converts to Islam report additional pressures, particularly regarding cultural customs and familial ties, which can amplify feelings of marginalization. Within the Muslim community itself, ethnic, national, and denominational differences give rise to multiple religious organizations. Although they can foster solidarity, they also risk over-fragmenting the wider ummah. While online social media offer valuable spaces for initial exploration of Islam, they can also heighten intra-group tensions. Study participants describe the community as marked by “quarrelers” and rigid religious standards that discourage open, inclusive dialogue. Overall, the research suggests that Polish Muslims face “troubled belonging” on two fronts: external exclusion stemming from societal mistrust, and internal divisions resulting from diverse religious and cultural practices.
References
- Aarset Monica Five, 2018, Conditional Belonging: Middle-Class Ethnic Minorities in Norway, in: Bendixsen Synnøve, Bringslid Mary Bente, Vike Halvard (eds), Egalitarianism in Scandinavia: Approaches to Social Inequality and Difference, Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
- Abdallah-Krzepkowska Beata, Górak-Sosnowska Katarzyna, Krotofil Joanna, Piela Anna, 2023, Managing Spoiled Identity: The Case of Polish Female Converts to Islam, Leiden: Brill.
- Abu El-Haj Thea Renda, Bonet Sally Wesley, 2011, Education, Citizenship, and the Politics of Belonging: Youth from Muslim Transnational Communities and the ‘War on Terror’, “Review of Research in Education”, 35(1): 29–59.
- Allen Kelly-Ann, Kern Margaret L., Rozek Christopher S., McInerney Dennis M., Slavich George M., 2021, Belonging: A Review of Conceptual Issues: An Integrative Framework, and Directions for Future Research, “Australian Journal of Psychology”, 73(1): 87–102.
- Balliet Daniel Junhui Wu., De Dreu Carsten KW, 2014, Ingroup Favoritism in Cooperation: A Meta-Analysis, “Psychological Bulletin”, 140(6): 1556–81.
- Bieger Laura, 2015, No Place Like Home; or, Dwelling in Narrative, “New Literary History”, 46(1): 17–39.
- Bourguignon David, Seron Elonore, Yzerbyt Vincent, Herman Ginette, 2006, Perceived Group and Personal Discrimination: Differential Effects on Personal Self-Esteem, “European Journal of Social Psychology”, 36(5): 773–89.
- Brehm John, Rahn Wendy, 1997, Individual-Level Evidence for the Causes and Consequences of Social Capital, “American Journal of Political Science”, 41(3): 999–1023.
- Cap Piotr, 2017, From ‘Cultural Unbelonging’ to ‘Terrorist Risk’: Communicating Threat in the Polish Anti-Immigration Discourse, “Critical Discourse Studies”, 15(3): 285–302.
- Claridge Tristan, 2020, Identity and Belonging, “Academy of Management Review”, 23(2).
- Dinesen Peter Thisted, Sønderskov Kim Mannemar, 2015, Ethnic Diversity and Social Trust: Evidence from the Micro-Context, “American Sociological Review”, 80(3): 550–73.
- Doney Patricia M., Barry James M., Abratt Russell, 2007, Trust Determinants and Outcomes in Global B2B Services, “European Journal of Marketing”, 41(9/10): 1096–116.
- Ewing Katherine Pratt (ed.), 2008, Being and Belonging: Muslims in the United States since 9/11, New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
- Ganesan Shankar, 1994, Determinants of Long-Term Orientation in Buyer-Seller Relationships, “Journal of Marketing”, 58(2): 1–19.
- Górak-Sosnowska Katarzyna, 2015, Between Fitna and the Idyll: Internet Forums of Polish Female Converts to Islam, “Hawwa”, 13(3): 344–62.
- Hunter John A. et al., 2017, Subjective Belonging and In-group Favoritism, “Journal of Experimental Social Psychology”, 73: 136–46.
- Kenyon Elizabeth, 2019, Troubled Belonging: Lived Experience and the Responsibility of Citizenship, “The Journal of Social Studies Research”, 43(1): 47–56.
- Kofoed Jette, Stenner Paul, 2017, Suspended Liminality: Vacillating Affects in Cyberbullying/Research, “Theory & Psychology”, 27(2): 167–82.
- Krotofil Joanna, Górak-Sosnowska Katarzyna, Piela Anna, Abdallah-Krzepkowska Beata, 2022, Being Muslim, Polish, and at Home: Converts to Islam in Poland, “Journal of Contemporary Religion”, 37(3): 475–93.
- Luhmann Niklas, 1979, Trust and Power, Chichester: Wiley.
- Lyon Alynna J., Uçarer Emek M., 2001, Mobilizing Ethnic Conflict: Kurdish Separatism in Germany and the PKK, “Ethnic and Racial Studies”, 24(6): 925–48.
- Lyons-Padilla Sarah, Gelfand Michele J., Mirahmadi Hedieh, Farooq Mehreen, Van Egmond Marieke, 2015, Belonging Nowhere: Marginalization and Radicalization Risk among Muslim Immigrants, “Behavioral Science & Policy”, 1(2).
- Maliepaard Mieke, Verkuyten Maykel, 2017, National Disidentification and Minority Identity: A Study among Muslims in Western Europe, “Self and Identity”, 17(1): 75–91.
- Mellor David, Stokes Mark, Firth Lucy, Hayashi Yoko, Cummins Robert, 2008, Need for Belonging, Relationship Satisfaction, Loneliness, and Life Satisfaction, “Personality and Individual Differences”, 45(3): 213–18.
- Morey Peter, Yaqin Amina, 2015, Muslims, Trust and Cultural Dialogue, “The Middle East in London”, 12(1).
- Morgan Robert M., Hunt Shelby D., 1994, The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing, “Journal of Marketing”, 58(3): 20–38.
- Obłąkowska Katarzyna A., Bartak Jakub, 2023, Zaufanie Polaków w życiu prywatnym i zawodowym, „Informacja Sygnalna z Badań Instytutu Finansów”, 6.
- Østergaard-Nielsen Eva K., 2001, Transnational Political Practices and the Receiving State: Turks and Kurds in Germany and the Netherlands, “Global Networks”, 1(3): 261–82.
- Özyürek Esra, 2015, Being German, Becoming Muslim: How German Converts to Islam Balance Their National Identity and Their Faith, LSE European Politics and Policy (EUROPP), blog.
- Pędziwiatr Konrad, 2010, Muslims in the Polish Media—the New Folk Devil, “Arches Quarterly”, 4(7): 89–95.
- Pędziwiatr Konrad, 2011, “The Established and Newcomers” in Islam in Poland or the Intergroup Relations within the Polish Muslim Community, in: Katarzyna Górak-Sosnowska (ed.), Muslims in Poland and Eastern Europe: Widening the European Discourse on Islam, Warsaw: University of Warsaw Press, pp. 169–82.
- Ponzanesi Sandra, 2019, Migration and Mobility in a Digital Age: (Re)Mapping Connectivity and Belonging, “Television & New Media”, 20(6): 547–57.
- Rogozen-Soltar Mikaela, 2012, Managing Muslim Visibility: Conversion, Immigration, and Spanish Imaginaries of Islam, “American Anthropologist”, 114(4): 611–23.
- Schilke Oliver, Reimann Martin, Cook Karen S., 2021, Trust in Social Relations, “Annual Review of Sociology”, 47(1): 239–59.
- Simpson Brent, 2006, Social Identity and Cooperation in Social Dilemmas, “Rationality and Society”, 18(4): 443–70.
- Slootman Marieke, Duyvendak Jan Willem, 2016, Politics of Belonging, from National to Personal: The Political Framing of ‘Dutch’ Identity and Ethnic Minority Citizens, in: Nicole Stokes-DuPass, Ramona Fruja (eds), Citizenship, Belonging, and Nation-States in the Twenty-First Century, New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
- Thunström Linda, Jones Ritten Chian, Bastian Christopher, Minton Elizabeth, Zhappassova Dayana, 2021, Trust and Trustworthiness of Christians, Muslims, and Atheists/Agnostics in the United States, “Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion”, 60(1): 147–79.
- Tyrberg Maria, 2024, The Impact of Discrimination and Support on Immigrant Trust and Belonging, “European Political Science Review”, 16(1): 18–34.
- Warmińska Katarzyna, 2001, Identity Formation in the Majority–Minority Relations, “Polish Sociological Review”, 2: 209–20.
- Zielińska Iwona, Pasamonik Barbara, 2021, Polarizing Moral Panics: A Theory and Its Application to the Refugee Crisis in Poland, “Deviant Behavior”, 43(12): 1543–57.
- Ziller Conrad, 2015, Ethnic Diversity, Economic and Cultural Contexts, and Social Trust: Cross-Sectional and Longitudinal Evidence from European Regions, 2002–2010, “Social Forces”, 93(3): 1211–40.
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
